Warrenside Tavern
Looking for a spot that’s perfect for a casual night out with friends or a family dinner? Warrenside Tavern in Stewartsville, NJ, might just be the place you’ve been searching for. Located at 511 NJ-173, this local favorite offers a welcoming atmosphere with moderate noise – ideal for enjoying a meal without the hustle and bustle of too much noise. It’s also a fantastic option for groups and families, with a vibe that’s both relaxed and inviting.
One of the highlights of dining at Warrenside Tavern is their selection of popular dishes. If you're a fan of hearty meals, the Prime Rib is a must-try. It’s tender, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. For those who crave a cozy, comforting dish, the Lobster Bisque offers a creamy and rich taste that’s hard to beat. If you’re looking for something a bit lighter, their Breaded Goat Cheese Salad and Spinach Salad are refreshing options. And for the salad lovers out there, the Cobb Salad provides a satisfying, filling meal with all the right ingredients.
The tavern's atmosphere makes it great for all ages. Whether you’re out with kids or catching up with friends, Warrenside Tavern has something for everyone. Plus, they offer happy hour specials – an added bonus for those looking to unwind after a long day. Whether you're grabbing a drink or enjoying one of their signature dishes, it’s easy to see why this restaurant is a go-to for locals and visitors alike.
Warrenside Tavern offers the perfect mix of delicious food, a welcoming environment, and a great atmosphere for those looking to enjoy a good meal with good company. If you find yourself in Stewartsville, NJ, make sure to check it out – you won’t leave disappointed.
Reviews
The Warrenside Tavern has been serving the residents and visitors of Stewartsville, New Jersey for decades and it has earned its spot within the community. The Warrenside Tavern has been open since 1924, which makes it (at least during this writing) one hundred years old and in that century, it is interesting how Stewartsville, New Jersey changed, as well as how much the world changed. In fact, 1924 was the year that J. Edgar Hoover was appointed the first director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (better known as the FBI) and 1924 also marked the first year that the first Olympic Winter Games was held in France. The world was still recovering World War I and World War II was years away. Anyway, the Warrenside Tavern has a great ambiance and the staff is friendly and professional. One thing that i will say is that in a world where change is normal, the Warrenside Tavern brings back a lot of nostalgia. Plus, while the menu doesn't veer too far from the expected, it is still enjoyable.
Food quality still very good. Menu has been cut back a bit. Service has generally improved at the tables but there's still room to improve at the bar.
I live local to this restaurant. This has been an easy access place for consistent food and service for 30 years , (while I have lived in the area.)
This is an old school bar with an atmosphere of history and warmth. The staff were lovely and our food was very good. Do not come here for a 5 star dining experience and complain. Come here if you want good simple food that it served hot and fresh by a server who is friendly. Come here if you want to saddle up to a bar that is adorned with brass memorial tags of those who are remembered to have sat there long before.
Food and drinks were excellent, except the Warrenside Old Fashion was a little weak. Outside needs to be modernized but as a previous reviewer stated "don't judge a book by its cover"